The careful evaluation of fire safety measures, namely “fire blankets” and “portable fire extinguishers”, in the distressing scenario of a fire engaging a person’s clothing underscores the marked advantages of portable fire extinguishers. This examination accentuates the importance of adopting effective and safe firefighting measures to protect both the victims and the staff. Using fire blankets in extinguishing fires involving an individual’s clothing carries inherent risks that could heighten the physical injury to both the victim and the rescuer.

Risks Associated with Fire Blankets

1. Close Proximity Risk: The fundamental mechanism of a fire blanket requires a rescuer to come into close physical proximity with the victim, increasing the likelihood of physical injury to both parties due to the flames and potential flare-ups.

2. Inducing Panic: The effectiveness of a fire blanket relies on its correct placement to smother the fire entirely. Any misplacement or incomplete coverage could fail to extinguish the fire or potentially cause it to spread, leading to escalated injuries and a prolonged dangerous situation.

3. Incomplete Extinguishment Hazard: The sudden smothering action might induce panic in the victim, making them more likely to move erratically, which could interfere with the correct placement of the blanket, making the situation more dangerous.

4. Heat Retention: Fire blankets retain heat and, if not removed promptly and carefully after the fire is extinguished, could cause continued burning or scalding injuries to the victim.

5. Physical Contact Injuries: Wrapping or patting the fire blanket around the victim to extinguish the fire entails a physical interaction that could cause or exacerbate injuries.

6. Residual Risks: Post-extinguishment, the cautious removal of the fire blanket to prevent further injury requires a skilled and gentle approach, which, under duress, may be challenging to achieve.

The Superior Safety of Portable Fire Extinguishers

1. Safe Distance Advantage: Portable fire extinguishers enable maintaining a safe distance while combating the flames, significantly reducing the risk of injury to the rescuer.

2. Swift and Effective Extinguishment: With the appropriate fire extinguisher, rapid flame suppression is achievable, providing an effective means to control and extinguish the blaze swiftly.

3. Reduced Physical Interaction: Unlike fire blankets, portable fire extinguishers require less physical interaction with the victim, reducing the likelihood of additional injuries.

4. Minimised Burn Severity: Quick and effective fire suppression translates to minimised burn severity, which is crucial for the victim’s immediate health and long-term recovery.

5. Lower Toxic Smoke Inhalation: Swift control and extinguishment of the fire reduce the amount of toxic smoke produced, lessening the risks associated with smoke inhalation.

6. Reduced Trauma: Rapid fire control can lessen the psychological trauma of fire incidents for both the victim and the rescuer.

7. Prompt Fire Control: Prompt control and fire extinguishment reduce the extent of burn injuries, leading to a less complex and shorter recovery period.

8. Lowered Medical Complications: Reducing burn severity and smoke inhalation decreases the likelihood of medical complications, accelerating recovery.

9. Minimised Scarring and Long-term Physical Impairment: Effective and immediate fire suppression helps minimise scarring and long-term physical impairment.

10. Training and Preparedness: Irish legislation mandates adequate training in using firefighting equipment, ensuring a rapid and effective response crucial in mitigating the severity of injuries. It is common for staff to receive training in using portable fire extinguishers. It would be highly unusual for staff to be trained in techniques to extinguish a live fire on a person using a fire blanket.

11. Legislative Compliance and Enhanced Safety Protocol: Adhering to stringent fire safety legislation augments safety protocols and fosters a culture of preparedness and response, epitomising a commitment to safeguarding lives and ensuring a robust response mechanism to fire emergencies.


The analysis emphasises that portable fire extinguishers provide a safer, more controlled means to tackle such dire fire scenarios. The ability to operate from a safer distance, coupled with the swift and effective extinguishment of fire, not only minimises the risk of physical injury to both the victim and the rescuer but also significantly curtails the adverse impact of the fire. Adherence to legislative guidelines through proper training and preparedness further amplifies the safety and efficacy of portable fire extinguishers as a superior choice for nurturing a responsive and safe environment during fire emergencies involving a person’s clothing.

Paddy McDonnell

2 Responses

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *